The V Spot Natural History Series ✦ Plate the First ✦ Of Weather & Deep Time
Two Million
Years of Rain
Pluvia Carnia — the deluge that drew the dinosaurs
being “Inner Ear musings”
In which a summer dinosaur dig in Portugal, an anthropologist’s ear, and two million years of rain are made to argue that the customer would be Recognised, not Tracked.
Classification of the Episode
- Period
- Triassic, Late
- Stage
- Carnian
- Age before present
- circa 234–232 millions of years
- Duration
- one to two millions of years of rain
- Supposed cause
- Wrangellia eruptions; carbon, heat, humour
- Chief casualty
- the ammonoids & the old dry world
- Chief beneficiary
- Dinosauria, then a minor order
Foreground: cycadeoids & ferns, the new wet flora.
Finn to his friends is what he is known to be called. To be in his company would make you want to be able to call him Finn. When I first met him in February in Dublin, he was a well heeled careful listener to a number of groswing, exploring Irish brands wheo were trying to understand more about the US market. Dave was part of a delegation brought over by Enterprise Ireland and on a 4 day junket to share and learn in equal measure. Dressed immaculately and in heritage style clothing (thanks to his Scottish roots no doubt), Dave listened with intent to the questions. During his first response, he told us he had experienced Irish retail and made a purchase, firmly putting his money where heritage lay. But he was captivated. Then, captivating. He responded with the gentle ease that he spoke with on our Watson Weekend Show on Friday. Speaking with wisdom and simplicity without pontificating, which would have been easy to do, given his background. Dave wanted to participate meaningfully. It would have easier not to.
During our pre alignment for the show he told us of his love of anthropology. It cannot be coincidental that his style of marketing is largely based on the human condition. His thought processes clear and language deliberate.
Start With the Dinosaur Dig
Let’s begin with dinosaurs.
Not the stale, fossilized kind of marketing thinking that refuses to evolve. I’m talking about actual dinosaurs, specifically, the ones Dave Finnegan spent his summer digging up in Portugal.
When Dave joined us on The Watson Weekend, he didn’t just come with stories of CMOs and brand playbooks. He came with dirt still under his fingernails. And a story true, scientifically valid, and metaphorically juicy that has been an inner ear worm for me since. (It has only been 72 hours) but we pre recorded and I was privy to what has was going to share. So this has been a long time in the making.
While on-site with a team from the Natural History Museum, Dave learned how the inner ear of a creature can tell you everything: whether it was cold-blooded or warm-blooded, agile or sluggish, predator or prey.
And most mind-blowingly of all, how, about 233 million years ago, a rainstorm that lasted two million years (yes, seriously) led to a climate so wildly transformative that it literally rewired evolution. Warm-bloodedness emerged. Dinosaurs took over.
i. anterior, ii. posterior & iii. lateral semicircular canals; iv. the cochlea; v. the vestibule.
The organ by which warm blood is told from cold.
Now hold that thought.
Curiosity and the Inner Ear of Commerce
A few weeks ago, I wrote this on LinkedIn:
"Culture > KPIs. Why curiosity could be your most underrated marketing metric."
It resonated. Said the egotistical consultant. In the sea of AI hacks, attribution wars, and cookie banner fatigue, the simple act of wondering again of feeling, listening, asking why feels increasingly rare. If we as marketers are to be curious, we as consumers want to be reconigzed. We willingly leave clues and signals, only largely to be ignored. What disservice this must be doing to our industry. Not recognizing the evolutionary path we are on. Nick Kaplan describes this period as Darwinian and it is not to sound dramatic or draconian, it is wayu worse than that. The dinosaurs taught us anything, it’s that evolution doesn’t reward dominance it rewards responsiveness.
And that’s where Dave dropped another truth bomb:
"Customers don’t want to be tracked. They want to be recognized."
Let that sit for a moment.
In just 10 words, Dave obliterated half the martech industry’s value proposition. He reframed a decade of digital surveillance as a failure of imagination. We didn’t build tech wrong because of what it does we built it wrong because of what we called it.
Words matter. And we’ve been using the wrong ones.
Anthropology > Attribution
As I mentioned earlier, Dave isn’t your typical CMO. He’s an anthropologist. An actual, studying-the-human-condition, bone-dust-on-his-shoes anthropologist. And that lens—that ability to see not just what people do but why they do it—is where his marketing philosophy stands apart. He shared that hs is on a course to study one new chapter a month, for life. A telling statement but said with the absolute satisfaction of someone who finds this vocational. I imagine marketing to him, is easy, understanding behaviors is fun and interesting. Dave is curious.
Anthropology, as he reminded us, is the pursuit of meaning over measurement. It's not enough to know the click-through rate; we need to know why they clicked. Or didn’t. Or rage-closed the tab and wrote a passive-aggressive tweet. This is a way better articulation of curiosity as a KPI.
Dave pointed out that we’re so obsessed with optimizing journeys and reducing friction, we’ve forgotten the thing that makes any journey worth taking: connection.
In a world full of personalization engines and AI-generated emails, what people actually crave isn’t another funnel nudge, it’s a moment that makes them feel seen. I have worked on this idea of moments for years now. Moments win marketing and retailing and trading is now about winning the day, not the week or the month. We wake up to win every day. This, right now, is exhausting. This, is not, going away.
Dave told a story about a Build-A-Bear experience where a 10-year-old girl born into iPads and TikTok lit up not because of a digital interaction, but because someone in-store recognized it was her birthday and called the whole team over to sing. We sometimes think of these experiences and cringe. Maybe we have forgotten that in those cringe moments a little bit of joy is exposed inside us or desire or longing.
For everything else, there’s (I won’t don’t worry.)
Tech’s Language Problem
Which brings me back to the language.
Tracking. Optimizing. Capturing. Converting.
We’ve built the entire modern marketing stack around words borrowed from surveillance, warfare, and mechanical engineering. Is it any wonder consumers feel like lab rats being A/B tested into submission? Maybe this is the Amazon effect at its most effective.
Dave’s quote is a full system override. It offers a new vocabulary for an industry badly in need of one:
This isn’t just semantics. It’s strategy.
Here’s the paradox we must embrace:
I think this is what it must feel like to be French. :)
And if that feels contradictory, congratulations you’re officially in the business of being human.
What the Data Actually Says
Plenty of studies back this up. I wanted to try and validate myself. Usually a glance in the mirror does that (You are old O Brien, get over it).
According to McKinsey, 71% of consumers expect personalization, and 76% get frustrated when they don’t find it. Yet simultaneously, 86% say data privacy is a growing concern.
So how do we reconcile this?
The answer isn’t more data. It’s better intent. Recognition over reduction. Understanding over optimization.
People are saying:
Behavioral economist Rory Sutherland once said: “A change in perspective is worth 80 IQ points.”
Well, a change in language might be worth a hundred brand points. Possibly more. And no one argues with Rory.
What If We’ve Been Building It All Wrong?
The reason this poiece took so long was that the real kicker in Dave’s insight is this: it’s not just marketing language that’s broken It’s the architecture that follows it.
When I think about it, it feels like this. If you start with “How do I track them?” You build a system optimized for consent forms, cookies, and opt-outs. (Slow down Jon, I know you are going to jump on this.)
If you start with “How do I recognize them?”
You build something completely different—something that might even feel... hospitable.
Recognition opens the door to:
- Identity without intrusion.
- Loyalty without bribery.
- Experience without surveillance.
It's not just more ethical. It's more effective. It is also language that can help us, as consumers, retrain our own expectations of what we want. We have come to expect things without thinking. We have become passive in our own interactions in most things we do. Thanks Social Media.
AI, Meaning, and the New Power Structure
One of Dave’s other mic-drop moments on the show was this:
“AI is shifting the power structure. It’s the Gutenberg press moment of our era.”
The printing press moved power from the few (clergy, kings, scholars) to the many (readers, writers, rebels). AI is doing the same putting expert-level tools in everyone’s pocket. I am still struggling with what is in front of us, AI wise and also why it is here at all. Having these tools to be effective for us will require expert level curiosity to match the tools. OTherwise we won’t’ realize their value.
But with great power comes... well, some really awful prompts. Let’s be honest. Oh Spiderman, you appear everywhere.
So the brands that win won’t be the ones with the most AI. They’ll be the ones who apply it with empathy.
They’ll use AI to amplify empathy, not automate it.
That means:
- Using data to make a customer feel seen, not segmented.
- Using personalization to create a sense of belonging, not behavioral nudges.
- Using AI to tell better stories, not faster spam.
The realization in the writing is that this will take time. As everything else speeds up, for the most community building slows down. Community was the other word mentioned. Community building takes time, effort and energy, something we fail to grasp. And time is a thief, it has been now for a decade, robbing us of our ability to be bored, engaged or interested all at the same time and instead forcing us to fill it with so called experiences and self improvement. When did we stop being happy progressing slowly. 1 class a month for life seems like a nice pace to me.
Belonging Beats Personalization
Dave also called out something we rarely talk about:
“Personalization is overrated. Belonging is the thing we’re really after.”
Boom.
We obsess over predictive algorithms and recommendation engines, and forget that the ultimate recommendation is community. People want to see themselves reflected in a brand—not just through a product recommendation, but through values, language, and cultural fluency.
If personalization is transactional, belonging is transformational.Belonging is another way to describe community. When we glibly talk about it at conferences we never describe the rate or scale of belonging our communities feel with us.
The Rituals We Forgot
Another insight: marketers used to understand ritual. Not in the performative, content-calendar sense but as a form of shared meaning.
Think about how Build-A-Bear turns a birthday into a production. Not every brand can do this, but then if a brand has no real purpose for being …. Or how Yeti doesn’t sell coolers they sell a rugged, slow-smoked ideal of life. In a test for Yeti, my team and I once stored ice in our Tundra 400 and after 23 days, we still had ice. The beers were gone, but the ice remained. Or how Arc’teryx designs half-theater, half-retail environments to tell stories of wind-swept summits, not SKUs.
These brands didn’t just sell stuff. They created clubs.
Dave shared this:
“A brand is a club you want to belong to.”
Rituals are always a part of the daily routine. If you can get into routine to be ritualistic or habitual, maybe you have a shot. This is, in large part, why Shopify do so well in the tech world. They are routine, their sales process is too. It is part of how agencies acr, talk, sell and hunt. All bound by this sense of belonging.
My Takeaways
Let’s land this heilcopter. Here’s what Dave Finnegan taught me—and hopefully, now you too:
- Words matter. “Track” vs. “recognize” changes everything.
- Empathy is an action, not a vibe. Investigate, don’t just guess. (vibe, sorry Rick. It’s everywhere. I blame you.)
- Belonging > Personalization. Sell community, not segmentation.
- AI is not the point. It’s the amplifier. Use it wisely.
- Recognition is a new strategic lever. Build for mirrors, not megaphones.
And most of all?
Thank You, Dave
For bringing anthropology, humanity, and an archaeologist’s chisel to the often plastic world of marketing. For reminding us that people want to be felt, not filed.
You gave us more than a quote.
You gave us a new language.
Let’s hope we’re smart enough to use it.
Now, over to you...
- Are you building for tracking or recognition?
- What brand made you feel seen recently? This is hard and maybe not always the purpose.
- What’s a better marketing word we should all adopt?
Drop it in the comments. I’m listening. And I’m curious.